rtems_semaphore_obtain problems identified
feng1 at bnl.gov
Wed May 2 14:18:30 UTC 2007
First, sincere thanks to all the heros who traced down thoses problems.
Joel Sherrill wrote:
> Chris Johns wrote:
> > Johan Zandin wrote:
> >> * RTEMS bug 1237 exists in all RTEMS versions and probably
> >> on most platforms. It is related to interrupts occuring
> >> during task switches and the symptoms are that stacks
> >> may grow too large, overwriting other memory areas.
> > I have looked over the patch and it only references the sparc cpu. I am
> > confused about the reference to "most platforms" reference. Do you mean just
> > sparc platforms ?
> This particular scenario was that a near continuous stream of high rate
> could result in barely getting back to the interrupted task and getting
> another interrupt
> and preempting from that task again and again without ever clearing off
> interrupt stack frames.
> This scenario is completely possible on other CPUs but is aggravated by
> the large
> interrupt stack frame on the SPARC. I suspect that design factors in
> the _ISR_Dispatch
> code that are port specific may avoid this problem on some ports.
> I'm not saying it couldn't happen on another architecture just that each
> port has to
> be evaluated on its own merits.
I actually observed the rtems_semaphore_obtain problems in the PowerPC
port long time ago since I was using mvme2307 BSP. My application will
work fine if I used other function to get around. However, at application
level, I really prefer to use rtems_semaphore_obtain b/c I have to port lots
of vxWorks applications, where rtems_semaphore_obtain were used.
After all, semaphore is very important in real-time application.
> Some ports run _ISR_Dispatch at the ISR
> level of the interrupt that generated the preempt so there would be a
> known limit
> on how many ISR Dispatches could stack.
> The SPARC runs ISR Dispatch with all interrupts enabled so the previous ISR
> is fair gain to occur again.
> > Regards
> > Chris
> > _______________________________________________
> > rtems-users mailing list
> > rtems-users at rtems.com
> > http://rtems.rtems.org/mailman/listinfo/rtems-users
> rtems-users mailing list
> rtems-users at rtems.com
More information about the users